March 29

Exiled by the Golden Dawn

(Affiliate disclosure: Some links on this blog may earn us a small commission at no cost to you. Every bit helps keep the lantern lit.)

On March 29, 1900, the London adepts of the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn voted to expel their founder and Chief, Samuel Liddell MacGregor Mathers. The man who had built the most comprehensive system of Western esoteric practice ever assembled—who had synthesized Hermetic Kabbalah, astrology, tarot, alchemy, geomancy, and Enochian magic into a single coherent initiatory structure—was cast out of his own creation.

The events surrounding his expulsion read less like the collapse of a serious occult institution and more like a West End farce: forged letters from imaginary German countesses, accusations of astral attack, a young man in a black mask and full Highland military regalia attempting to seize a London temple by force, W.B. Yeats helping a police constable eject him from the premises, and a court case in which a judge drily observed that he had noticed no indication that any of the parties were Freemasons. And yet from this spectacular chaos emerged the entire modern Western magical tradition. If you have ever cast a ritual circle, worked with the Tarot as a spiritual system, studied the Kabbalah in an esoteric context, or encountered the magical philosophy underlying Thelema or Wicca, you are standing in the ruins of this explosion.

The Order’s Foundations

The Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn was founded in London on March 1, 1888, by three men: William Wynn Westcott, a London coroner with serious occult interests; William Robert Woodman, a senior Rosicrucian; and Samuel Liddell MacGregor Mathers, who was by any measure the creative genius of the operation. The founding mythology rested on a set of sixty pages of encrypted text—the Cipher Manuscripts—which Westcott claimed to have obtained through a Freemason contact and deciphered to reveal the outlines of five initiation rituals. Accompanying these was a correspondence purportedly with Anna Sprengel, a German adept and representative of a secret Rosicrucian organization called Die Goldene Dämmerung, authorizing the three men to establish a new temple in England.

Scholars now almost universally believe that the Cipher Manuscripts were a deliberate fabrication, and that Anna Sprengel either never existed or was a convenient fiction. What mattered was what Mathers built on top of them. Working with breathtaking synthetic intelligence, he assembled the Golden Dawn's initiatory curriculum—the Grade system, the rituals, the magical theory—from the widest possible range of sources: the Kabbalah, the Hermetic Corpus, Renaissance magic, Enochian angelic magic derived from John Dee, astrology, alchemy, geomancy, the Tarot. The result was not a museum but a living system, internally coherent and practically powerful.

By the peak of its influence in the 1890s, the Golden Dawn had initiated over three hundred members across five lodges, and its roster read like a Who's Who of late Victorian intellectual and artistic life. William Butler Yeats joined in 1890 and became one of its most serious magical practitioners, his poetry saturated with Golden Dawn symbolism to a degree that cannot be fully understood without knowing the system. Florence Farr, feminist actress and lover of both Yeats and George Bernard Shaw, became the Chief Adept in Anglia. The tea heiress Annie Horniman bankrolled significant portions of the operation. Arthur Machen, Algernon Blackwood, Constance Wilde, and Pamela Colman Smith—who designed the world's most influential Tarot deck, the Rider-Waite—all passed through the temple doors. The Order admitted women and men as equals at a time when virtually every other fraternal organization excluded women entirely. And then came Aleister Crowley.

The Catalyst

Crowley joined the Outer Order in November 1898 at Mark Masons Hall. He was twenty-three years old, in possession of a considerable inheritance, and already distinguished by the prodigious magical ego that would define his entire career. He made rapid progress and applied to the Second Order—the inner circle of practicing adepts—the following year. The London temple refused him, offering no official explanation. The unofficial explanation, communicated to him privately, was essentially that the Order was not a reformatory for people with his reputation for sexual license and libertine lifestyle.

Crowley, not a man who accepted rejection gracefully, wrote to Mathers in Paris. Mathers, by this point operating from a distance in increasingly autocratic fashion and increasingly suspicious of a conspiracy among the London members, defied the London temple's decision and personally initiated Crowley into the Adeptus Minor grade at the Ahathoor Temple in Paris on January 24, 1900. This act, more than any other, precipitated the crisis.

Florence Farr, exasperated by the ongoing bickering and Mathers's high-handed management from Paris, wrote to him suggesting the Second Order should perhaps simply be dissolved. Mathers, convinced this was a maneuver by Westcott—whom he had long suspected of treachery—responded by sacking Farr. He then sent the London membership a thunderous letter accusing Westcott of having fabricated the entire Sprengel correspondence that had founded the Order in the first place.

“NEVER been at any time either in personal or in written communication with the Secret Chiefs of the Order, he having either himself forged or procured to be forged the professed correspondence between him and them.”

This was either a devastating revelation or an act of spectacular self-destruction, depending on how one reads it. If Westcott had forged the founding correspondence, the Order's entire mythological legitimacy was built on a lie—but that lie had been Mathers's foundation for twelve years of extraordinary work. The London members took the accusation at face value, found it disqualifying for Westcott, and then immediately applied the same logic to Mathers: if the founding documents were fraudulent, what exactly was his authority based on?

And on March 29, 1900, the London adepts voted to expel him.

The Battle of Blythe Road

Mathers did not accept this quietly. He dispatched Crowley to London with instructions to seize control of the Order's premises at 36 Blythe Road in West Kensington—the Vault of the Adepts, the most sacred space in the London temple.

What followed has passed into occult legend as the Battle of Blythe Road, and the factual record is considerably funnier than the legend suggests. Crowley arrived at the premises wearing, as Yeats would later report to his patron Lady Gregory, "a black mask and in full Highland costume"—kilt, MacGregor tartan, and a gilt dagger at his side. He had been calling himself the Laird of Boleskine for months, had bought an estate on the shores of Loch Ness, and had taken to signing letters "Aleister MacGregor" in imitation of the Chief Adept.

He broke into the building, changed the locks, and dispatched letters to all the Second Order adepts summoning them to appear before him for questioning within three days. Yeats, who had been the primary leader of the revolt against Mathers, arrived with another member the following day, had words with the landlord, and returned with a constable. Crowley was ejected from the premises. The London membership retained control of the building.

Yeats's letter to Lady Gregory, written on April 24th, captures the entire flavor of the affair with magnificent understatement: "The envoy is really one Crowley, a quite unspeakable person. He is I believe seeking vengeance for our refusal to initiate him. Mathers like all despots must have a favorite and this is the lad."

The matter proceeded to court. Mathers sought an injunction to prevent Crowley from publishing the Order's secret rituals. The judge ruled against him, and the Lord Justice's observation—“I have not observed any indication that you are, either of you, Masons”—brought the house down.

Aftershocks

The formal schism of 1900 was, in institutional terms, the end of the original Golden Dawn. Mathers formed a successor group in Paris called the Alpha et Omega in 1903, styling himself Archon Basileus, and continued working with his wife Moina—the extraordinary occultist and artist who was also the sister of philosopher Henri Bergson—until his death in 1918. The London membership fractured into competing factions: A.E. Waite's Christian-oriented Independent and Rectified Rite dissolved in the mid-1910s; the Stella Matutina carried the more magical current forward into the 1940s.

The Order's second life, however, was more consequential than its first. Crowley, expelled and furious, went on to develop Thelema—the magical-religious system anchored by The Book of the Law, received in Cairo in 1904—which drew directly on the Golden Dawn's technical foundations while radically departing from its philosophical framework. The entire architecture of modern Western ceremonial magic: the structure of the ritual circle, the system of elemental correspondences, the use of the Kabbalah as an organizing map, the working relationship between the Tarot and the Tree of Life—all of it was either created or synthesized by Mathers and his colleagues, then disseminated through the Order's records.

Those records were published to the world by Israel Regardie between 1937 and 1940. Regardie had worked as Crowley's personal secretary in the late 1920s, had later been initiated into the Stella Matutina, and made the deliberate decision to put the entire Golden Dawn curriculum into print before it was lost entirely. The publication caused outrage among surviving members who considered it a catastrophic breach of oath. It also ensured that everything Mathers had built survived the twentieth century intact, freely available to any serious student.

Wicca, the modern Pagan religion that emerged publicly in England in the 1950s through Gerald Gardner, drew directly on Golden Dawn ceremonial structure—the circle, the quarters, the consecration of tools, the initiatory grade system. The modern Tarot, in virtually every deck in use today, is built on the framework Pamela Colman Smith and Arthur Edward Waite created within the Golden Dawn tradition. The Kabbalah as it is studied and practiced in contemporary Western esotericism is almost entirely the Kabbalah as Mathers understood and systematized it.

Mathers’ Legacy

Samuel Liddell MacGregor Mathers is one of the more poignant figures in the history of Western esotericism. He was genuinely brilliant and genuinely difficult—a polyglot who had taught himself French, Latin, Greek, Hebrew, Gaelic, and Coptic; a scholar who had published serious translations of the Key of Solomon, the Kabbalah Unveiled, and the Book of Abramelin; a magical architect of extraordinary synthetic imagination. He was also increasingly autocratic, financially irresponsible, and prone to claiming a direct working relationship with Secret Chiefs whose existence and communications he could never verify to anyone else's satisfaction.

His death certificate, when he died in Paris in 1918, listed no cause of death. For years his burial site was unknown, leading some to claim—in the spirit of the tradition he had built—that he had achieved immortality and simply left. The grave has since been found in Paris. He died in a city that was not his home, estranged from the institution he had created, outlived by its influence.

There is something fitting about the fact that the Golden Dawn imploded so dramatically—and that the implosion produced such extraordinary consequences. Every major magical tradition of the twentieth century carries Mathers's fingerprints. Thelema, Wicca, the modern Hermetic revival, the contemporary Kabbalah: all of it flows, in some measure, from the work of a self-educated London occultist who called himself MacGregor, claimed descent from a Highland clan, built a temple on forged correspondence from a fictional German countess, and was expelled from his own creation by the poet who would one day win the Nobel Prize in Literature.

(Every day, Modern Occultist News will present "This Day in Occult History" and will dive into the birthdays, rituals, breakthroughs, and crucial moments that shaped today's many esoteric traditions. From the Hermetic revival to Witchcraft, from Crowley to cyberspace, we'll bring the best stories and latest trends to today's own modern occultists everywhere.)

Modern Occultist